New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Feb 1, 2020 8:30 AM
#301
I would say the anime ended as my gaming session ended. It crashed. In all seriousness, it started off good and ended bad. it's also bad because it ended and ending is bad XD It's good that it ended tho |
Feb 1, 2020 2:09 PM
#302
shiro_kai said: By their logic the show ended, therefore is bad To end is bad, the journey not so much Although this ending was like lost potential |
Feb 1, 2020 6:30 PM
#303
Really? I was hoping this series ending will be more sensible. It was so anticlimactic -_- I'm so sadness T^T Well whatever, they messed up and we watched them :ı |
Feb 1, 2020 6:58 PM
#304
Feb 2, 2020 12:17 AM
#305
Quick question, after the endibg we see Magase with a kid, is that Seizaki's kid(100% confirmed)? |
Feb 2, 2020 1:07 AM
#306
the ending left me with the feeling"Why am I wasting my time for this ?" |
Feb 2, 2020 7:15 AM
#307
I saw many people mentioned Kado then I found out the original creator was also Kado's creator. Omnipotent enemy, talking about what's right and wrong, and strong start but bad ending. This show is similiar to Kado. I was really excited for this anime. I thought this was the second Monster but it turned out to be worse and worse after the president story began. . . . The main story is basically to differentiate what's good or evil. Seizaki killing the president was seen as good thing among those who knew about president's condition but of course that's evil thing from the people outside's perspective. Killing the president to prevent the law was bad choice. Magase will eventually succeed in making the law established either way. But by killing the president, Seizaki basically 'suicide' because it means capital punishment which is ironic. In the last moment I assumed he was shot by someone. Like Kado, this anime heavily shows Christian's philosophy on life. Suicide is not a sin in Christian but it is sin in Buddhist which is dominant religion in Japan. I guess the author and Shiniki's religion is Christian? |
Feb 2, 2020 9:23 AM
#308
I think anybody here is telling enough about how good this anime concept but how disappointing the ending is. I believe it is better for us to figure out about what actually this anime producers expect from us by showing us this kind of ending or this kind of antiklimaks, triggering?thinking? Expecting? Maybe. That's what i want to make sure of, im sure you all here too... i mean come on, this anime gives me chills in every episodes, they could give us better for the finale... ATTENTION PLEASE: I also want to ask, is there anybody here knows what is being said in the end of the opening, the shady words in the end of the opening... it can also be heard in the 12th eps when magase met zen in the rooftop...please help me figure it out |
Feb 2, 2020 8:24 PM
#309
[quote=HaXXspetten]Uhm... what? That's it? I really don't get it. Why did he even have to shoot the president to begin with, but more importantly that was such an anticlimatic ending anyway. So much plot potential that they never did anything with and it all feels like it amounted to nothing in the end I still liked the show a lot for most of its airing but... yeah that wasn't a great endin HaXXspetten said: i think he killed the president because if Alex killed himself, it would tell the world that suicide is ok. When he was talking to the girl he said if suicide is ok he would kill himself.Uhm... what? That's it? I really don't get it. Why did he even have to shoot the president to begin with, but more importantly that was such an anticlimatic ending anyway. So much plot potential that they never did anything with and it all feels like it amounted to nothing in the end I still liked the show a lot for most of its airing but... yeah that wasn't a great ending >_> |
Feb 3, 2020 3:47 PM
#310
Most people already discussed what I wanted to say anyways soo... Me during the last 5 minutes: REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
Feb 3, 2020 11:39 PM
#311
Great Anime apart from episode 11. And people who don't know why he shot the president were you even watching lol. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:23 AM
#312
anime-prime said: I don't understand the point of this show. Shock factor? Evil wins in the end? Was this entire detective thriller just an excuse to talk philosophically (and lazy philosophy at that) and to kill the president of the united states? What was the point? I don't need happy endings but I need some sort of closure that shows that watching these 12 episodes had a purpose. What a waste of potential to an amazing premise. The purpose was to explore the relationship of good and evil as well as to think of what they truly mean. This is a story meant to make you think, not just entertain you. It did the job well. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:25 AM
#313
jedman said: And people who don't know why he shot the president were you even watching lol. You nailed it. That great dilemma was solved for both characters in one dramatic moment. Good was prioritized over self. They did what they believed was good. |
Feb 6, 2020 9:41 AM
#314
Just finished watching Babylong today.. Now Magase Ai would be added to my list of the worst Villain ever.. It is so frustrating that they all had the resources they need, they have FBI/CIA but they cant track or kill single woman.. The show has so many loopholes.. Im a bit disappointed because the story is really good, the conversations, the quotation, the debate, and the colliding of every persons opinion and ideology.. And that ending is a f**king cliffhanger damn it.. |
Feb 6, 2020 10:38 AM
#315
Feb 6, 2020 3:04 PM
#316
Zen was under Magase's control since the interrogation, he didn't actually see her on the rooftop after killing Alex but that was just a figment she implanted in him. She couldn't be there in 30 minutes considering she was in Japan. |
Feb 7, 2020 4:56 AM
#317
Seeing the ratings fall so badly gives a warm feeling in my heart. Such a bad closure. What is point of introducing story elements, if they're just gonna take a huge dump in it? |
Feb 8, 2020 2:48 AM
#318
Ilovebeanbag said: Seeing the ratings fall so badly gives a warm feeling in my heart. Such a bad closure. What is point of introducing story elements, if they're just gonna take a huge dump in it? Anime still good least in first half This fact don't change it Also there might be second season Novel don't end yet |
Feb 8, 2020 2:51 AM
#319
TGAvi said: novel ended. No second season.Ilovebeanbag said: Seeing the ratings fall so badly gives a warm feeling in my heart. Such a bad closure. What is point of introducing story elements, if they're just gonna take a huge dump in it? Anime still good least in first half This fact don't change it Also there might be second season Novel don't end yet |
Feb 8, 2020 10:03 AM
#320
Ryuseishun said: Sorta long ramble here, cause I can’t keep the bottle cap on anymore. That was perhaps one of the worst fucking conclusions to a mystery / psychological series that I’ve ever seen in my entire life. What was accomplished? Nothing. What was taught here? Nothing. What was the ultimate point of all that meandering? Nothing, absolutely nothing. Magase’s Quirk....I mean, Esper ability.....I mean, Gifted abil—.....ahhh fuck it, i dunno what to describe. That shit never had any sort of set-in-stone explanation. She’s perhaps one of the worst excuses of a villain I’ve ever witnessed. Whatever bit of backstory tossed in for her is silly and bareboned. She’s not sophisticated, she acts so, but there’s no true deeper intent, just a redundant af ideal about what’s good and evil. She wins in the end and is now probably gonna prey on the mc’s son now, but what was the point? It was so anticlimactic and inconclusive, considering how the series kinda lost its spirit by episode 7. Any visual cues this show are mostly too hollow without much foundation to really have much deeper theme, context, or meaning. Tbh, episode 3 was the point where I should’ve noticed the red flag, due to how the course of the story suddenly changes to chasing some crazy bitch with supernatural psychic powers to “talk” people into suicide. Zen himself was as underwhelming as everyone else in the cast. One can argue about fitting oneself into the characters’ shoes and parallelism or realism, but seriously.......does realism alone always constitute good storywriting? No, ofc not. The one good thing I can take away from the show: the soundtracks, cause they help with adding to the tension (or at least attempts at tension). If this was how the original source material went, this series was already full of problems to begin with, regardless of bad pacing or not (only 3 LN vol, 2 manga vol). And people compare this to Psycho Pass s1 or even say it’s better than latter...I can’t really comprehend that, tbh, cause Psycho Pass had a sci-fi dystopia setting whereas Babylon does not unless one wants to consider Magase’s “Quirk”. Magase as a character would’ve been more befitting in a more supernatural setting. I don’t even want to talk in detail about the redundancy about the numerous discussions about this “good Vs evil” subject. The conversation went from thought-provoking to childish real quick. Was this just more of a leeway for Magase to have her way that easily because a bunch of god damn politicians can’t come to a straightforward and obvious conclusion that was right there in front of them the whole time? I guess so. With all that being said, the foundations for this show were too weak to begin with. It’s like trying to drive a big luxury cruiser without any propellers or engine. It felt like a show where the brainstorming just stopped halfway. You pretty much summed up everything I wanted to say. Yes, this is a mystery but that doesn't mean the show should be incredibly ambiguous and leave a lot of loose strings untied. I can live with the fact that Magase won but what happened to Seizaki? The suicide law? Everything and everyone else? I'm going to be a child pounding my fists on the table and just say, I'm bitter as fuck that Magase didn't suffer even the slightest in this series. Everyone around her did but she didn't. People are saying she's the best villain ever and I think she's just a fucking troll. Most people praising her wouldn't be doing so if she wasn't an attractive woman. Go ahead and beg to differ but we all know those people are lying. |
臭い- |
Feb 8, 2020 10:06 AM
#321
Bibimbapski said: Ryuseishun said: Sorta long ramble here, cause I can’t keep the bottle cap on anymore. That was perhaps one of the worst fucking conclusions to a mystery / psychological series that I’ve ever seen in my entire life. What was accomplished? Nothing. What was taught here? Nothing. What was the ultimate point of all that meandering? Nothing, absolutely nothing. Magase’s Quirk....I mean, Esper ability.....I mean, Gifted abil—.....ahhh fuck it, i dunno what to describe. That shit never had any sort of set-in-stone explanation. She’s perhaps one of the worst excuses of a villain I’ve ever witnessed. Whatever bit of backstory tossed in for her is silly and bareboned. She’s not sophisticated, she acts so, but there’s no true deeper intent, just a redundant af ideal about what’s good and evil. She wins in the end and is now probably gonna prey on the mc’s son now, but what was the point? It was so anticlimactic and inconclusive, considering how the series kinda lost its spirit by episode 7. Any visual cues this show are mostly too hollow without much foundation to really have much deeper theme, context, or meaning. Tbh, episode 3 was the point where I should’ve noticed the red flag, due to how the course of the story suddenly changes to chasing some crazy bitch with supernatural psychic powers to “talk” people into suicide. Zen himself was as underwhelming as everyone else in the cast. One can argue about fitting oneself into the characters’ shoes and parallelism or realism, but seriously.......does realism alone always constitute good storywriting? No, ofc not. The one good thing I can take away from the show: the soundtracks, cause they help with adding to the tension (or at least attempts at tension). If this was how the original source material went, this series was already full of problems to begin with, regardless of bad pacing or not (only 3 LN vol, 2 manga vol). And people compare this to Psycho Pass s1 or even say it’s better than latter...I can’t really comprehend that, tbh, cause Psycho Pass had a sci-fi dystopia setting whereas Babylon does not unless one wants to consider Magase’s “Quirk”. Magase as a character would’ve been more befitting in a more supernatural setting. I don’t even want to talk in detail about the redundancy about the numerous discussions about this “good Vs evil” subject. The conversation went from thought-provoking to childish real quick. Was this just more of a leeway for Magase to have her way that easily because a bunch of god damn politicians can’t come to a straightforward and obvious conclusion that was right there in front of them the whole time? I guess so. With all that being said, the foundations for this show were too weak to begin with. It’s like trying to drive a big luxury cruiser without any propellers or engine. It felt like a show where the brainstorming just stopped halfway. You pretty much summed up everything I wanted to say. Yes, this is a mystery but that doesn't mean the show should be incredibly ambiguous and leave a lot of loose strings untied. I can live with the fact that Magase won but what happened to Seizaki? The suicide law? Everything and everyone else? I'm going to be a child pounding my fists on the table and just say, I'm bitter as fuck that Magase didn't suffer even the slightest in this series. Everyone around her did but she didn't. People are saying she's the best villain ever and I think she's just a fucking troll. Most people praising her wouldn't be doing so if she wasn't an attractive woman. Go ahead and beg to differ but we all know those people are lying. Yea, lots of things unanswered, misdirections everywhere. I could go on, but my previous comment pretty much did the job already, so I won't be redundant here xD Yea, anyone saying Magase is a great villain probably has an extremely bad interpretation of what truly constitutes a well-written antagonist in general. |
Feb 9, 2020 4:26 AM
#322
Such a time wasting anime. |
|
Feb 9, 2020 11:27 AM
#323
Not a bad finale, but I felt kinda disappointed. Not that I was expecting a definitive closure where everything got explained—I don't mind open endings—, but this ending left a lot unresolved and no many clues to draw our own conclusions. I couldn't tell what the message of the series is. Could it be whatever action, whatever decision you make somehow or other leads to evil? That's a bit depressing if you ask me. It seems pretty clear that Zen killed the president to prevent him from committing suicide, which would have been seen as if the president concluded suicide was a good thing and, therefore, a definitive push for the approval of the Suicide Law throughout the world. Being this true, Zen decided to sacrifice himself, but this doesn't imply the Suicide Law stops spreading. At least it'd had made more sense if Zen had then killed Magase, since it seems apparent she's responsible for the whole thing of the suicides. After having killed the POTUS, killing Magase wouldn't have been a big deal. Another odd thing is how Magase managed to escape from a building full of policemen. Well, some killed themselves, but not everyone. What happened to the Suicide Law? What was the connection of Magase with Itsuki? And most importantly, who was Magase, what were her motives and her purposes? Too many questions unanswered. The author's premise was good, but in my opinion, the conclusion wasn't very well executed, as if he didn't know how to conclude it. The good thing is that it makes us think about it, what's always welcome from a series. In my opinion, this episode could have worked better as a prelude to the finale, instead of the closure for the series. Still, I enjoyed the series. Overall the direction was good, and the art and soundtrack were nice. I liked the story and how it developed, it succeeded in keeping me interested throughout all the series without getting bored. In short a good series. |
Feb 9, 2020 4:04 PM
#324
shiro_kai said: By their logic the show ended, therefore is bad Checkmate Babylon |
Feb 10, 2020 2:10 PM
#325
Feb 10, 2020 5:04 PM
#326
So at the end of the show, Zen and the President "Triumph over" Ai Magase and foil her plan. The president asks Zen to shoot him, and Zen makes that self sacrifice, pretty much damning himself. Is there any other show the good guys win by taking such counter intuitive actions? I really appreciate it. So as another poster said, they thought Ai went back to Zen's wife and son to slaughter them, which may be true if she is angry about being beaten. I think Zen was shot by a third party on the roof, the 2nd shot sounds very different than the first one. If he is still alive, that might be why Ai went to his family. Zen might be in Guantanamo Bay getting water poured over him. |
Feb 11, 2020 10:27 AM
#327
Okay, what the actual fudge? So many bits to gripe on, honestly. An elite player being the US President itself was ridiculous but I can take that with a little laugh. However, this goes more than just that. Downright ridiculous seeing how the G-7 leaders were playing "right and wrong" there out of nowhere last episode. I'm afraid that goes even beyond the realms of acceptable fiction for me, I'm sorry. Seriously, I might've just scratched a fair amount of my hair trying to comprehend and come to terms with this finale but I just can't... I'll start off with positives exclusively of this episode. Zen and the President coming to an understanding and effectively nullifying Magase's plan was an interesting course of development, I've to say. As the @TheCodiakBear rightly highlighted, there aren't many shows that go through with such an intriguing counter route after all. Another matter would be the answer to the "good vs. evil" trivia which I honestly don't think I've a full grip on just yet but it's certainly something to ponder upon, I reckon. Sadly, I can't muster up the interesting or the willingness to go for it and let's dive more into that now... First and foremost, it's no understatement to say that the US President was a main character for this second half. Naturally, that means we spend a lot of time seeing him in action (screen time-wise) and there's always something about him standing out, and that's his calculative and somewhat cautious approach to matters at hand. Now, please enlighten me as to how this very person deemed it "safe" to connect with the female, supposedly Ai Magase at the time, when they were uncertain of Magase's quirk-like abilities in the first place. Leaving aside the mundane matter of why even bother, of course and I'll certainly get more on to this in due time. Surely, one even with average IQ could infer that this would be playing right into the hands of the criminals, no? Baffling, just baffling. Now, on to the yet-another-bewildering part of the US President's intervention. Are you seriously expecting me to believe that a single Mayor in Japan who's supposedly beyond the Japanese Prime Minister's reach himself for unclear reasons with a single hostage managed to force the US President's hand to take such an action? I'm aware of what was at that stake then but literally playing along and throwing caution to the wind like that was incredible in other ways for sure. So what exactly is Itsuki Kaika's plan and relationship with Ai Magase anyway? How'd this little stint end up influencing the world in relation to the Suicide Law? But wait, what is Ai Magase's ability as to rile up the international community to this extent and ffs even beat them black and blue? Whore of Babylon? I don't know if I managed to impressively miss out on numerous little subtle details somehow but there has definitely got to be some issues with the presentation/script-writing or whatevs here for certain. From what I could gather, I agree with the theory that Ai Magase is off to chasing Seizaki's family in revenge and Seizaki getting shot from a third-party too. Now, these are things that are "okay" leaving open. Seizaki probably didn't go for the shot either, as testament to his ideals (the President understandably an extreme case). Overall, this second half was simply a bloody mess through and through. What seemed like a very unique and appreciable theme at first just ended up being far too convoluted and unrealistic, disappointingly. Credit though as the cinematography was on point to the very end, that little stare-off after the tense entry and "bang..." from Ai Magase was quite nerve-chilling actually. Ai Magase has been quite the stunning villain to have as well (courtesy to the amazing performance from the VA too, easily my favourite performance of the year in fact) but a few dots and blanks makes it a little hard to really have a feel for her, I guess. Can't quite get the right words at the moment. Loved the ED and Op themes of the show too and kudos to Yutaka Yamada for his amazing work! God, that Magase theme is on par with Licht und Schatten for me and that's saying a lot, trust me. I'd like to end off with a bit more of a personal experience judgement kind of thing, if that even makes sense. An after-thought of the ride, if you will. Throughout episodes 1-6, I was honestly hooked. Seeing how the buildup plus some of the features I highlighted abovee in full force was handled was charming and indeed very alluring, if I do say so myself. But then came episode 7. Don't get me wrong, it was like the icing on the cake so definitely great undoubtedly but it brought a little worry alongside. And that was something along these lines of "will it all be justifiable from my point of view at the end of the ride?". Basically, whether it'd end up to be a possible ascendance from thereupon as I come to comprehend the motives and whatnot or a big mess beyond my reach. And seeing the response, I was certain which side majority belonged to but that's not enough to turn me away, I'm afraid. Little did I know that it'd end up to this extent for my case though... With all things in mind, I have to give this a 5/10. Initially, I was considering a generous 6 but there's just one too many drawbacks for that, I'm afraid. Going the worldwide route was always going to be asking for trouble, and that's exactly what happened here. I've seen many people compare this to Sekaisuru Kado for obvious reasons (the creator being the prime, from what I could gather) and it totally feels like deja vu in a way, xD. Y'know, I value the experience a lot so it's not often that I would end up giving a harsh rating simply for the ending alone (Sekaisuru Kado being a great example of that) but this really ended up giving a bitter taste with ample lost potential and etc. so a real pity from my side. Maybe I'll bump it to a very generous 6/10 later this morning but who knows. |
_MushiRock11_Feb 11, 2020 10:38 AM
#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni |
Feb 11, 2020 6:09 PM
#328
Gibberish. Absolute nonsense, a truly garbage show. Might actually be the worst anime I ever actually watched all the way through. An astounding achievement there, I have to applaud Babylon for being the absolute worst thing ever for me. Congrats, you are number 1 at something. At boring me, disgusting me and pissing me off. 1/10, wish I could give it a lower score. |
Feb 12, 2020 3:41 AM
#329
Ilovebeanbag said: TGAvi said: novel ended. No second season.Ilovebeanbag said: Seeing the ratings fall so badly gives a warm feeling in my heart. Such a bad closure. What is point of introducing story elements, if they're just gonna take a huge dump in it? Anime still good least in first half This fact don't change it Also there might be second season Novel don't end yet Mado nozaki said will complete novel https://twitter.com/babylon_anime/status/1222203272741707777?s=09 |
Feb 12, 2020 3:45 AM
#330
gswelcome said: Gibberish. Absolute nonsense, a truly garbage show. Might actually be the worst anime I ever actually watched all the way through. An astounding achievement there, I have to applaud Babylon for being the absolute worst thing ever for me. Congrats, you are number 1 at something. At boring me, disgusting me and pissing me off. 1/10, wish I could give it a lower score. Don't be stubid First half episodes 1-8 still good and enjoyable Ending don't change this |
Feb 12, 2020 3:50 AM
#331
TGAvi said: maybe I'll change my mind then. But it is trash until then. Such a fucking disappointment. Grossed me out. How could someone fuck up the story so badly in just 10min? Is the last volume completed or still in works?Ilovebeanbag said: TGAvi said: Ilovebeanbag said: Seeing the ratings fall so badly gives a warm feeling in my heart. Such a bad closure. What is point of introducing story elements, if they're just gonna take a huge dump in it? Anime still good least in first half This fact don't change it Also there might be second season Novel don't end yet Mado nozaki said will complete novel https://twitter.com/babylon_anime/status/1222203272741707777?s=09 |
Feb 12, 2020 1:55 PM
#332
TGAvi said: gswelcome said: Gibberish. Absolute nonsense, a truly garbage show. Might actually be the worst anime I ever actually watched all the way through. An astounding achievement there, I have to applaud Babylon for being the absolute worst thing ever for me. Congrats, you are number 1 at something. At boring me, disgusting me and pissing me off. 1/10, wish I could give it a lower score. Don't be stubid First half episodes 1-8 still good and enjoyable Ending don't change this They weren't enjoyable at all for me, the anime was incoherent from start to finish, just devolved even more into gibberish in the second half. Characters were one dimensional with nothing to make me care about their welfare. Full of legal and philosophical nonsense instead of plot. Even Magase Ai didn't have a personality, a grinning psychopath is not enough. Got to disagree even further on the ending, if a show doesn't stick the landing it simply isn't as good no matter how great the rest of it was. Of course for me Babylon was never great in the first place. |
Feb 12, 2020 2:41 PM
#333
This show was sometimes ridiculous, sometimes edgy, but still entertaining enough. It could've been something more with such good premise, but at least it tried. Oh, and people who whining about "why there is no explanation to Magise's power?!!' can go eat shit. Seriously, spoon feeding is worst thing ever. |
Feb 13, 2020 7:24 AM
#335
gswelcome said: TGAvi said: gswelcome said: Gibberish. Absolute nonsense, a truly garbage show. Might actually be the worst anime I ever actually watched all the way through. An astounding achievement there, I have to applaud Babylon for being the absolute worst thing ever for me. Congrats, you are number 1 at something. At boring me, disgusting me and pissing me off. 1/10, wish I could give it a lower score. Don't be stubid First half episodes 1-8 still good and enjoyable Ending don't change this They weren't enjoyable at all for me, the anime was incoherent from start to finish, just devolved even more into gibberish in the second half. Characters were one dimensional with nothing to make me care about their welfare. Full of legal and philosophical nonsense instead of plot. Even Magase Ai didn't have a personality, a grinning psychopath is not enough. Got to disagree even further on the ending, if a show doesn't stick the landing it simply isn't as good no matter how great the rest of it was. Of course for me Babylon was never great in the first place. Anime in first half was have intresting ideas And good plot This fact don't change it Magase have backstory in episode 5 Zen is good MC If its not anjoyable for you of start Then drop it Don't completed it |
TGAviFeb 13, 2020 7:31 AM
Feb 13, 2020 3:47 PM
#336
A little confused at why Magase is most liked character tbh |
Feb 15, 2020 6:22 PM
#337
Ah yes... this thread is filled with the classic "you didn't like the show because you didn't understand it 2deep4u" logic. Got anything else? What a waste of time. One of the most frustrating experiences I've ever had with anime. The premise was already flawed to begin with but I was willing to overlook that much despite my grievances of how it oversimplifies things not until it got to the point where the plot twists are just becoming beyond stupid. Episode 7 especially was a horrible one. Irrelevant and dumbed down characters. Throwing around a bunch of concepts/ideas/topics or whatever without doing anything with it or doing the bare minimum scratching the surface. Loose ends. Bad villain. Yay for open endings. A convenient excuse for the author to keep the audience talking about it. 1/10 because I'm currently pissed. Might increase it later or someday if I'm feeling generous enough. |
Feb 15, 2020 8:13 PM
#338
I have dropped after watching episode 07 but I decided to just give a look episode 12 and... thank goodness I have dropped this earlier. Pretty ridiculous. Amazing how this even has a mean score above 7.0 That is why mean score isn't trustful when deciding whether or not watching an anime. Easy 1/10 |
Vi-Feb 15, 2020 8:17 PM
Feb 17, 2020 8:22 PM
#339
Why do people take the time to watch shows that they obviously don't like/understand only to give them 1/10. makes no sense to me. I usually research an anime enough to know if it's something I am going to enjoy before watching it, or I drop it pretty quick if doesn't meet my expectations. |
Feb 19, 2020 5:29 AM
#340
Dr_Kon said: RealTheAbsurdist said: I honestly thought the characters arguing what's good and evil, only to come to that conclusion, was stupid. I thought: good = benefiting as many people as possible with the least amount of effort and harm evil = harming others. Like, suicide, good and evil, are topics that philosophers have argued for centuries in long writings, and I just felt like this show just oversimplified all that. I just don't get why with how the show was built, how Seizaki was built, he'd refuse to kill Magase. Like, he killed the president, a good guy he cared about. But even that made no sense: "To end = evil, Alex will commit evil, therefore I will embody evil by killing him instead." Like, what?? I will try to elaborate a bit more this train of thought, both mine and yours. It is quite important for everyone to start distinguishing between the difference of philosophy and sophistry. There are many writings about "philosophical" concepts and paradoxes that, in essence, end up being sohpistries. Rhetoric is a key characteristic of any sophist and depending on how a concept is presented to the audience with the help of strong rhetorical argumentation, you can sway the opinions in one way or another, but without really contributing to philosophy, which is at heart the art of acquiring true wisdom and coming closer to the one and only absolute, catholic truth as ancient philosopher Socrates put it. You can reach conclusions with sophistry too, but these are not the absolute, universal truths and, more often than not, rely on public approval through logical and sensible argumentation, rather than delving deeper into the psyche and in the understanding of universe where the psyche resides. There have been countless attempts to understand "good" and "evil" but more often than not the conclusions are based on sophistries. As Plato put it before in his work "allegory of the cave", there are two worlds, there is the world of senses and materials (our world, the fake world according to him) and there is also the world of ideas (the real world) in which all the absolute truths exist. And it is the duty of the philosopher to break out of his chains in the cave, climb up and find the exit to the real world, and once he finds it to come back and liberate all the other prisoners in the cave by enlightening them with the truths of the real world. In our simplistic human logic, if we are presented with a situation of "good" and "evil" in which we have to decide between saving many and saving one, most of the times we would end up choosing many. But then again, who decides what's good or evil? What does that good and evil entail exactly? Is it always important to do the good? Is it not the evil that gives importance to the good and make good exist in the first place? Does true wisdom lie in always doing what's good? So many questionmarks and so few true philosophers unfortunately. But here is another very interesting paradox to examine on this matter: "Socrates trial" is a prime example and paradox in this "good" and "evil" discourse: Ancient Athenians had to decide whether they will sentence Socrates to death for introducing heretic ideas ("new Gods" as it is written in the prototype) that corrupt the minds of young people who admire him, or whether they will let him free to continue "corrupting" the Athenian society and youth. This is a classic case of conflict between what constitutes good and evil, who decides which side is which and whether the life of one matters more than the life of the many. If to continue is good, then keeping a great figure as Socrates alive would have been good, but from the Athenian authorities' side the good was to continue with the current status quo and without having "problematic" people like Socrates questioning it which would result in questioning the whole structure and disturb the lives of many as well as quesiton the sacrifices of many. These things and debates are complex, hence, the attempt of the writer of Babylon to completely dumb the whole concept down and generalize it, as you said, felt like a blasphemy to all these great minds in human history who spent their entire lives contemplating on these matters. Finally, when it comes down to writing a tragic story and portray tragic characters there are certain standards that have been established since a few millenia ago in ancient Greek tragedy, especially when it comes to portrayal of tragic heroes. It is not a coincidence that even to this day, university students pursuing classic literature, theatre studies, film studies and every other course related, study the ancient tragedies to better understand the fundamental both of tragedy and tragic heroes. I am not majoring in any of these, however, I have read a fair enough amount of books on that matter out of personal interest. Diverging from these standards doesn't make your writing special, progressive or different, it just makes the writing bad as it does not conform with neither causality, nor the structure of human nature/psyche nor balance and harmony in human life. I will not go in depth because I have already written a lot of stuff, anyone with keen interest could research these notions further, but there are certain basic elements that need to be present to render a figure tragic and complete a cycle of tragedy namely: 1) Hubris (the arrogance and defiance of the limits and boundaries that results in sin/evil/wrongdoing); 2) Hatei (the blindness of the mind sent by "God" for your initial wrongdoing; the blindness caused by hatei will result in you committing more wrongdoings, until the point you commit a very grave sin that causes divine nemesis); 3) Nemesis (the grave sin you committed earlier will cause the nemesis of "God", in other words the divine wrath and divine revenge); 4) Tisis (the divine punishment to end this vicious cycle of wrongdoings and which results usually in the destruction/death of the tragic figure); Christianity, when emerged centuries later, implimented these concepts in it too. With respect to the anime, the writer confuses religious symbolisms in the story (not uncommon for Japanese fascinated with western culture and religion to do that) and ends up mis-introducing the whore of Babylon, a symbolic figure representing the incarnation of seduction, as a "God" who passes divine judgement (nemesis) and punishment (tisis), which is bollocks in more ways than one because the purpose of punishment (tisis) is to end the vicious cycle of evil and maintain the balance and harmony (a "good" thing), although here we have the whore of Babylon, a completely irrelevant symbolism in the matters of good and evil (unless the writer wanted us to re-evaluate whether John in his "Revelations" presented the whore as a "good thing" lol) being that caring divine figure that does "good" by eliminating Seizaki, the wrongdoer, go figure. I wish Japanese writers abstained from introducing unfamiliar to them western religion concepts just because they sound cool. I presume all the above is essentially your "Like what?" summary that you rightfully concluded and so did I with different wording in my initial post. No matter how much further someone analyzes that series, there is only disappointment in more ways than one. On a final and more practical note, many countries in G7, especially USA, have a hard-line policy of not negotiating with terrorists no matter what. But here in the show magically everyone forgot about the FBI guys who interrogated Seizaki and found that there is a series of murders and something is fishy here, or the fact that US president is not responsible for matters of internal affairs in Japan or the protection and safety of Japanese citizens, because any intervention entails breach of sovereignty, but I guess these are small letters in front of all the other anomalies in the show. "Babylon" wanted to be too many things in 12 episodes and ended up being none, just a wasted potential. Damn, very well said! I couldn't have said any better. This series and Pet are the polar opposites for me. The former had a captivating start but ended up so abruptly as opposed to the latter which started out kinda bland but turns out great so far. Bibimbapski said: This! I admit that I was first captivated by the series because of how stunning Magase is, aside from psychological/mystery being my favorite genres.Ryuseishun said: Sorta long ramble here, cause I can’t keep the bottle cap on anymore. That was perhaps one of the worst fucking conclusions to a mystery / psychological series that I’ve ever seen in my entire life. What was accomplished? Nothing. What was taught here? Nothing. What was the ultimate point of all that meandering? Nothing, absolutely nothing. Magase’s Quirk....I mean, Esper ability.....I mean, Gifted abil—.....ahhh fuck it, i dunno what to describe. That shit never had any sort of set-in-stone explanation. She’s perhaps one of the worst excuses of a villain I’ve ever witnessed. Whatever bit of backstory tossed in for her is silly and bareboned. She’s not sophisticated, she acts so, but there’s no true deeper intent, just a redundant af ideal about what’s good and evil. She wins in the end and is now probably gonna prey on the mc’s son now, but what was the point? It was so anticlimactic and inconclusive, considering how the series kinda lost its spirit by episode 7. Any visual cues this show are mostly too hollow without much foundation to really have much deeper theme, context, or meaning. Tbh, episode 3 was the point where I should’ve noticed the red flag, due to how the course of the story suddenly changes to chasing some crazy bitch with supernatural psychic powers to “talk” people into suicide. Zen himself was as underwhelming as everyone else in the cast. One can argue about fitting oneself into the characters’ shoes and parallelism or realism, but seriously.......does realism alone always constitute good storywriting? No, ofc not. The one good thing I can take away from the show: the soundtracks, cause they help with adding to the tension (or at least attempts at tension). If this was how the original source material went, this series was already full of problems to begin with, regardless of bad pacing or not (only 3 LN vol, 2 manga vol). And people compare this to Psycho Pass s1 or even say it’s better than latter...I can’t really comprehend that, tbh, cause Psycho Pass had a sci-fi dystopia setting whereas Babylon does not unless one wants to consider Magase’s “Quirk”. Magase as a character would’ve been more befitting in a more supernatural setting. I don’t even want to talk in detail about the redundancy about the numerous discussions about this “good Vs evil” subject. The conversation went from thought-provoking to childish real quick. Was this just more of a leeway for Magase to have her way that easily because a bunch of god damn politicians can’t come to a straightforward and obvious conclusion that was right there in front of them the whole time? I guess so. With all that being said, the foundations for this show were too weak to begin with. It’s like trying to drive a big luxury cruiser without any propellers or engine. It felt like a show where the brainstorming just stopped halfway. You pretty much summed up everything I wanted to say. Yes, this is a mystery but that doesn't mean the show should be incredibly ambiguous and leave a lot of loose strings untied. I can live with the fact that Magase won but what happened to Seizaki? The suicide law? Everything and everyone else? I'm going to be a child pounding my fists on the table and just say, I'm bitter as fuck that Magase didn't suffer even the slightest in this series. Everyone around her did but she didn't. People are saying she's the best villain ever and I think she's just a fucking troll. Most people praising her wouldn't be doing so if she wasn't an attractive woman. Go ahead and beg to differ but we all know those people are lying. |
electromagnetoFeb 19, 2020 5:52 AM
I just realized that all of my favorite characters, beside being stunningly beautiful, also happen to be exceptionally skilled murder machines. \('-')/ I'm level |
Feb 19, 2020 2:40 PM
#341
I usually love adaptation of novels, but to be honest, it was one of the most weird experiences in my life. Of course, I felt that it would be strange when orgasm was shown as a shot in the head, but I really did not expect the show to end with the protagonist killing the American president. This is madness. 6 or 7 from 10, I don't know. |
Feb 23, 2020 7:12 AM
#342
Umm what did I just watch? So I assume that Zen killed the president so he wouldn't commit suicide because if he did that would have sent the wrong signal to the whole nation and also to the girl that wanted to kill herself. He basically sacrificed the president in order to protect the rest of the world kinda? The ending is a mess tho...did zen really die? Why and how did he? Did he shoot himself because of Magases influence? Magase was an interesting villain but interesteing isn't enough when nothing really makes sense in the grand scheme of things. I feel like the show just fell apart after the halfway point... |
Feb 23, 2020 1:48 PM
#343
good - is to continue; bad - is to end. Finally, years of depression and suicidal thoughts profited by predicting this conclusion! xD It the same when I learned that my way of thinking already exist as nihilism and determinism. :P But honestly they should get extra 5 minutes to explain plot lines, like black guy is fully aware that Zen is "innocent" so they probably explained truth to his wife, Did people learned definition of Good and Evil?, etc. About Magase, She couldn't die (should but couldn't) because if there is good there must be also evil. |
Manga recommendation: - Spy x Family (Ch.114/? - biweekly) | Sakamoto Days (Ch.208/? - weekly) - MARRIAGETOXIN (Ch.123/? - weekly) | Machi and Oboro (Ch.23/? - biweekly) - Make the Exorcist Fall in Love (Ch.87/? - biweekly) - Monochrome Days (Ch.17/? - biweekly) Anime recommendation: - Deca-Dence (Finished) | Wave, Listen to Me! (Finished) - If My Favorite Pop Idol Made It to the Budokan, I Would Die (Finished) - Diary of Our Days at the Breakwater (Finished) |
Feb 23, 2020 10:30 PM
#344
Genres: Mystery, Psychological, Thriller Should've tag supernatural instead of psychological because you know, one involves science and the other doesn't. good - is to continue; bad - is to end. It took this anime 12 episodes to come up with this philosophical statement as if it's controversial but it is currently a popular opinion/morality in our society. |
Truth is absolute but human perception of truth is always relative. |
Feb 25, 2020 2:48 AM
#345
Vi- said: I have dropped after watching episode 07 but I decided to just give a look episode 12 and... thank goodness I have dropped this earlier. Pretty ridiculous. Amazing how this even has a mean score above 7.0 That is why mean score isn't trustful when deciding whether or not watching an anime. Easy 1/10 Yout taste is shit Episode 1 to 7 still good and ejoyable So just shut up |
Feb 25, 2020 2:50 AM
#346
Dull_Lull said: Ah yes... this thread is filled with the classic "you didn't like the show because you didn't understand it 2deep4u" logic. Got anything else? What a waste of time. One of the most frustrating experiences I've ever had with anime. The premise was already flawed to begin with but I was willing to overlook that much despite my grievances of how it oversimplifies things not until it got to the point where the plot twists are just becoming beyond stupid. Episode 7 especially was a horrible one. Irrelevant and dumbed down characters. Throwing around a bunch of concepts/ideas/topics or whatever without doing anything with it or doing the bare minimum scratching the surface. Loose ends. Bad villain. Yay for open endings. A convenient excuse for the author to keep the audience talking about it. 1/10 because I'm currently pissed. Might increase it later or someday if I'm feeling generous enough. Plot twist was good You should rewatch first 6 episodes to see it |
Feb 25, 2020 2:52 AM
#347
One of best anime in 2019 I glad Novel still ongoing So going to catch up with novel |
Feb 25, 2020 7:44 AM
#348
In the eye of the storm:
Truths:
What was that end?
Was it worth it? Well. Depends on a person. It was not boring and generic at least. Big kudos I was able to follow and comprehend the story contrary to Big Order, Taboo Tatoo and Index the 3rd. And if you did not see those three you've never tasted real defeat. |
Feb 25, 2020 8:50 PM
#349
mannnn i'm only logging into post to vent and stop being stuck on this ending. There's just sooooo many unresolved plot holes. I'm not even mad that the villain wins or the all rhetorical thin-veiled 'i am deep' philosophical good/evil BS. I'm mad they spent 12 episodes constructing a world and characters that were ultimately irrelevant just to fit the whore of babylon allegory. Magase character is one of the worst villains ever because she literally has no character building and has the most OP hypnosis power ever. I mean she makes people commit suicide left and right, but conveniently lets others live for political, social, and economic gains???? Itsuki is apparently just a giant plot pawn that gets way too much screen time. Why set up the battle between Zen and Magase only to not show Zen's resolution with her? that's just straight trolling. Why have Magase get her hands dirty by physically killing the female assistant with her own hands? Yea sure drive Zen to the dark side, but why did she have to physically do it, is the assumption that the assistant was mentally strong like Zen and would've had to be corrupted first and it was just faster to have her die manually? in which case, again why not show Zen's finale other than being an open-ended troll. Why even have the slight back story of Magase being a real person at all? Why have Magase go thru the effort of even dealing with politics? Why not just have Magase kill Zen with her own hands? Just so many things that seem filled in arbitrarily just to fit the narrative with no actual purpose. Idk this could have easily been 24 episodes with actual character development and plot resolution. Instead it feels like a friend rolled up with windowless van filled with unlimited free <insert choice of candy/drug/sex/vice> then after a short ride kicks you out into the desert and drives off laughing never to be seen again. Fun at first but then wtf bye. |
Feb 26, 2020 3:28 PM
#350
Deus said: What the fuck was that ending. I've never been more disappointed with a show before. There is a lot of bad anime but at least they don't try to be serious and just go with it, but this one tried to be "deeP" too hard, and ended up being just stupid. It'd have been better if Zen just killed Magase (Who should've actually been in the building) after the President, and then got shot from a helicopter. And no post-credits bullshit scene. That'd have been a perfect ending and saved the anime. 2/10 - Massive disappointment You lost all credability when you added a naruto gif. Yeah great taste there bud. Go cry somewhere else. Im sorry this show wasnt like your typical shonen shit. Grow up. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Babylon Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Oct 6, 2019 |
158 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Mar 1, 5:59 AM |
|
Poll: » Babylon Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Oct 6, 2019 |
82 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Mar 1, 5:50 AM |
|
Poll: » Babylon Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Oct 6, 2019 |
107 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Mar 1, 5:25 AM |
|
» People don't recommend watching babylon! Is it too disturbing to watch?FarshidBG - Mar 2, 2022 |
18 |
by burbels
»»
Jan 20, 12:39 PM |
|
Poll: » Babylon Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jan 20, 2020 |
121 |
by mal_user_2022
»»
Jan 20, 11:30 AM |